The Dark Knight Rises

"Perhaps he’s wondering why someone would shoot a 

man before throwing him out of a plane."

It was a bittersweet feeling walking out of The Dark Knight Rises was over but all good things must come to an end. Since Batman Begins in 2005, Christopher Nolan’s Batman trilogy has served as the high watermark of what a great superhero movie could be. After The Dark Knight’s incredible success, combined with its inconclusive ending, expectations for The Dark Knight Rises were astronomically high. For the most part, it is my opinion that this film will meet most people’s expectations and in many ways exceed them.

Being the third entry in a successful trilogy is an enormous amount of pressure to put on a single film. It is near impossible to make something that can live up to years of expectations and hype. Combined with this, the third movie must always be both a complete story on its own while having the additional burden of wrapping up all the loose ends that the first films opened up. The Godfather, X-Men, Terminator, Back to the Future, Spiderman, Pirates of the Caribbean, Alien, The Matrix and Jurassic Park all examples of trilogies that started off strong and ended in a trainwreck due to the failures of the third entry.

The second film in a trilogy is generally considered to be the best as it doesn’t have to introduce any of the characters or concept of the story, nor does it have to have any conclusive ending (generally ending on a cliffhanger). This is a large reason why The Dark Knight was so successful and universally loved. It had an entire film dedicated to the introduction of the main character and didn’t need to have a complete ending as that could be done in a third film. The first thing I hear when people talk about The Dark Knight Rises is whether or not it is better than The Dark Knight. I honestly don’t understand why this matters. Some elements of the third film are better than the second film while others are worse. They are both incredible movies that are well worth your time and money.

 The Dark Knight Rises begins eight years after the last film left us. Gotham city is at peace thanks to the Dent Act (named as a memoriam to the fallen Harvey Dent), a piece of legislation put in place to imprison major criminals without chance of parole. Bruce Wayne (Christian Bale), who used Batman to take the fall for Dent’s crimes, can no longer wear his mask without risking arrest or death by the police. Having lost Rachel and his entire family, he feels he has nothing left to live for and has become a recluse in the rebuilt Wayne manor, locking himself up in his room and waiting for his life to end. When he receives an unexpected visit from a cat burglar (Anne Hathaway) who steals his fingerprints, he comes out of hiding to investigate. When he returns to Gotham City, Wayne hears whispers of a new threat, Bane (Tom Hardy), whose background and intentions are unclear. Wayne must then decide if he can take the risk and return Batman to Gotham to find out what Bane is doing stop to him.

The film’s overall plot takes the best elements of the Knightfall series of comics (the origins of Bane), Frank Miller’s The Dark Knight Returns (Batman returning to Gotham after an extended absence), and No Man’s Land (the idea of an isolated Gotham run by gangs). Other plot pieces show up from the comics (John Blake’s character is an amalgamation of many characters, the inclusion of Catwoman, etc.) and I can’t imagine any Batman comic book fan being let down by the story. The screenwriters (Chris Nolan, Jonathan Nolan and David S. Goyer) clearly have a significant love and depth of knowledge of the Batman canon and their efforts to incorporate as much as they can while still tell an original story are admirable.

The plot is very good and tries to tackle a lot of multiple stories at once. While nowhere near as convoluted as The Dark Knight, there is sometimes too much going on and someone that is half paying attention will easily get lost as the film jumps from story to story quickly. There are some great twists in the third act and a great effort is made to tie the story back to the original Batman Begins and make this a cohesive three-part story, which is impressive as these films were never originally planned to be a trilogy.
 

I personally like the elements of the story that have to do with Bruce Wayne’s personal weaknesses and his attempts to hide them by being Batman, and the third film has as much of this as Batman Begins did (perhaps more). I found that in the previous two films it was difficult to see Wayne and Batman as one character and you almost had to constantly remind yourself that they were the same person. In the third film, since Wayne is so weak and is trying to hide it by wearing the costume, that disconnect between characters is overcome. During his first encounter with Bane, when he has only been back in the Batsuit for a number of days, you can truly see the fear in Wayne’s eyes that not even his mask can hide.

My favorite part of the Batman comics has always been the idea of Batman being a symbol that gives hope to the citizens of Gotham. Batman Begins introduces this idea as one of the motivations Wayne has for creating Batman, but Dark Knight did not deal with this much at all. I was overjoyed to see this being a constant theme throughout the third film. There is a scene (minor spoilers) where thousands walk down a street to face an army of thugs at the other end. You can see that they are terrified and aware they could be facing their death at any moment. Then suddenly, Batman flies over them in the Bat (his awesome flying machine) and all of the cops remember they have this anonymous hero who will always be there. He gives them all a boost of courage and they storm down the street towards the thugs. There are a handful of scenes like this in the movie and they are truly fantastic.

The cinematography in this film is quite simply mind-blowing. Nolan is the only director today who actually uses the IMAX camera, and I would much rather see modern film moving in that direction rather than making everything 3D. Over an hour of the movie is filmed with the IMAX camera, and there is a size and scale achieved with the camera that normal 16 mm film just cannot compare with, 3D or not. If you can, make an effort to see this film in IMAX; it makes an enormous difference and is absolutely worth it. Hans Zimmer’s score is mostly pieces of the fantastic score from the previous films, but the new chanting for Bane is truly exceptional. Zimmer had people on the internet record themselves doing the chant and then submit it to him so he could mix them all together and the end result is awesome. 

The ensemble cast is made up of some of the best actors alive right now old, young and old, and the interactions between characters are so great I almost wish there was more dialogue than action (there is a great mix of both). Bale is the perfect Bruce Wayne, Michael Caine adds a level of age and wisdom to Alfred, and Gary Oldman adds an dramatized, almost Shakespearean quality to Gordon. Joseph Gordon-Levitt as John Blake ends up being one of the main characters and has an enormous amount of screen time and his character arc, though predictable, is set up well.

Many people doubted Anne Hathaway’s ability to play Catwoman “correctly.” I am not exactly sure what anyone thinks the correct way to play Catwoman would be, as the last two times the character was portrayed in live-action cinema were Halle Berry’s abysmal Catwoman and Michelle Pfeiffer’s over-the-top turn in Batman Returns. The bar is not set very high to begin with. Regardless, Anne Hathaway has proved herself over years of movies that she is a fantastic actress, so I am not exactly sure where all this skepticism came from. She’s been nominated for and won multitudes of acting awards (no Oscars yet, despite a nomination) and has been in some great movies. I keep hearing how everyone is “surprised” at how well she performed in TDKR, so if you are surprised when an accomplished actress does a great job of acting, I would hate to see your reaction when something actually surprising happens.

Tom Hardy is fantastic as Bane and is quickly becoming one of the top actors working right now. Though only about 20% of his face is showing, his exaggerated use of his eyes and eyebrows, combined with his booming voice, make Bane an effective and ominous character. The dialogue has been rerecorded and remixed since the intro was screened before Mission Impossible 4 (you could barely understand a word he was saying) and sounds a million times better, though there were still a few moments where it is a tad unclear (usually because the music is so loud). There is much discussion as to whether his performance is as good as Heath Ledger’s as the Joker in The Dark Knight, and I feel it is incomparable due to Hardy’s limitations of wearing the mask. I also don’t think Bane is as important to the story of the third film as the Joker is to the second, so the character does not need to carry quite as much weight. 

Spoilers begin.

I absolutely loved the John “Robin” Blake addition in the final scene of the movie. Christian Bale once said he would not do these films if Robin was ever a part of the story, and I really liked how Nolan was able to fit Robin into his vision of Batman without it being too campy (as you don’t realize Blake is Robin until the very end). Many people misinterpreted the information of his name being Robin whereas John Blake would become Robin once he inherits the batcave, but it is actually that he has always been Robin (ie. Batman’s sidekick). If he chooses to follow Batman’s footsteps, it is more likely that he would become Nightwing or another type of masked hero. Nolan has said he will not make any additional sequels and I sincerely hope that Warner Bros doesn’t try to continue his story without him.

While I was among the many comic book dorks who correctly predicted Talia Al Ghul’s involvement in the story (there are very few female Batman characters, so the additional casting of Marion Cotillard as a new female character was noteworthy), what I did not predict is how they would include her in the story. In the comics, it is actually Bane (not Talia) who grows up in the prison and then escapes in a different way than in the film (I’m not going into it here, use Wikipedia). When the movie discusses Wayne’s belief that it was Bane who was the child who escaped from the prison, all the comic book fans in the audience also believe that to be the case because that is similar to what happens in the comics. By including both Talia and Bane in the prison, Nolan was able to amalgamate Bane’s and Talia’s comic backstories into a twist that both comic fans and non-fans alike would be surprised by. This dedication to making a story that can be surprising to the entire audience is commendable.

End spoilers.

Whether or not The Dark Knight Rises is better than The Dark Knight is irrelevant. What matters is that, in an age of a constant onslaught of superhero films, it stands tall above the rest of them (including Avengers) and shows what, when taken seriously, a superhero film can actually accomplish when taken seriously. Nolan’s Batman movies will join the ranks of the original Star Wars, Lord of the Rings, Indiana Jones, Bourne, Toy Story, and other legendary trilogies that you will put an aside an entire weekend with your kids to watch. Nolan has truly knocked it out of the park with these movies and Batman has finally gotten the ending he deserves.